America in the World • AP US History
Is America
a Better Version
of Itself?
1898
Then
1945
Now
Thesis Statement
Yes, the United States is a better version of itself in 1945 than in 1898 due to the improved quality of life, strong economy, and reduced corruption.
Historical Context
1890–1945 Overview
In the 1890s, the United States emerged as an imperial power, annexing Hawaii and gaining territories after the Spanish-American War, while industrialists like Andrew Carnegie shaped a booming—yet unequal—economy through monopolistic practices.
The Progressive Era brought reform movements that challenged corporate power, with presidents Theodore Roosevelt and William Howard Taft using federal authority to break up trusts, while activists like Jane Addams fought for social welfare and suffragists demanded political equality.
The United States reluctantly entered World War I in 1917, and afterward the Senate's rejection of the League of Nations reflected a nation torn between global engagement and isolationism, as the Roaring Twenties brought unprecedented prosperity alongside racial tension and social upheaval.
The Great Depression, worsened by President Hoover's reluctance to intervene, devastated millions of Americans and eroded faith in laissez-faire capitalism, setting the stage for Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal, which fundamentally transformed the relationship between the federal government and its citizens.
World War II forced the United States into a global leadership role, and despite moral failures such as Japanese American internment, the war's end in 1945 left America as the world's preeminent economic and military power—a nation that, while still imperfect, had grown stronger, more organized, and more committed to international responsibility than it had been in 1898.
Key Personalities
Historical Figures
The men and women whose decisions shaped America from 1890 to 1945
Frances Perkins
1930s, 1940sAs FDR's Secretary of Labor—the first woman to serve in a U.S. Cabinet—Frances Perkins was the driving force behind the New Deal labor reforms, championing the Social Security Act, minimum wage laws, and the 40-hour workweek, fundamentally reshaping the American worker's rights.
Queen Liliʻuokalani
1890sThe last reigning monarch of Hawaii, Queen Liliʻuokalani opposed the American-backed coup that overthrew her government in 1893, symbolizing the tension between U.S. imperial expansion and the sovereignty of indigenous peoples.
Henry Cabot Lodge
1900s, 1910sA staunch nationalist and Senate leader, Henry Cabot Lodge led the opposition to the Treaty of Versailles and the League of Nations, arguing that American sovereignty must not be subordinated to international bodies.
Alice Paul
1910s, 1920sA radical suffragist and feminist leader, Alice Paul organized the picketing of the White House and drafted the Equal Rights Amendment, pushing the suffrage movement beyond its moderate roots toward full legal equality for women.
Herbert Hoover
1920s, 1930sHoover's faith in voluntarism and opposition to direct federal relief during the Great Depression led to widespread suffering and political collapse, serving as a cautionary tale about the limits of laissez-faire governance in times of crisis.
Fred Korematsu
1940sFred Korematsu defied Executive Order 9066 and challenged the constitutionality of Japanese American internment all the way to the Supreme Court, becoming an enduring symbol of civil liberties resistance against wartime fear and racism.
William McKinley
1890sPresident McKinley led the United States into the Spanish-American War in 1898, acquiring Guam, Puerto Rico, and the Philippines and marking America's decisive turn toward overseas imperialism and great-power competition.
Theodore Roosevelt
1900s, 1910sA progressive Republican and foreign policy hawk, Theodore Roosevelt wielded the "Big Stick" abroad while busting trusts at home, redefining the presidency as an active force for both domestic reform and international power projection.
W.E.B. Du Bois
1910s, 1920sIntellectual giant and co-founder of the NAACP, W.E.B. Du Bois challenged Booker T. Washington's accommodationist approach and demanded full civil and political equality for Black Americans through scholarship, activism, and the foundational concept of the "double consciousness."
Huey Long
1930sThe flamboyant Louisiana governor and senator, Huey Long built a powerful political machine on populist rhetoric, challenging FDR from the left with his "Share Our Wealth" plan and demonstrating the dangerous appeal of demagogic politics during the Depression.
Albert Einstein
1940sA refugee from Nazi Germany, Albert Einstein warned FDR of Germany's nuclear ambitions in his famous 1939 letter, helping spark the Manhattan Project—a scientific and moral turning point that changed the nature of warfare and geopolitics forever.
Jane Addams
1890s, 1900sNobel Peace Prize laureate and founder of Hull House, Jane Addams pioneered the settlement house movement in Chicago, providing vital social services to immigrants and the poor while shaping the intellectual foundations of American social work and progressive reform.
William Howard Taft
1910sTaft's presidency was marked by an aggressive "Dollar Diplomacy" in Latin America and a conservative interpretation of the presidential role that frustrated progressives, eventually leading to the 1912 party split with Roosevelt that handed the election to Woodrow Wilson.
Frank Kellogg
1920sAs Secretary of State, Frank Kellogg co-authored the Kellogg-Briand Pact of 1928, an idealistic multilateral treaty that renounced war as an instrument of national policy—a noble gesture that nonetheless failed to prevent the conflicts of the 1930s and 1940s.
A. Philip Randolph
1930s, 1940sFounder of the Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters, A. Philip Randolph leveraged the threat of a March on Washington to pressure FDR into signing Executive Order 8802, banning discrimination in the defense industry and marking a pivotal step in the long civil rights struggle.
Winston Churchill
1940sBritain's wartime prime minister, Winston Churchill was America's closest ally in World War II, forging the "Special Relationship" and shaping the post-war international order at conferences like Yalta and Potsdam, though his views on empire often clashed with American ideals of self-determination.
Historical Analysis
Scores & Analysis
Each figure is scored on their contribution to American progress. Bold text reflects historical thinking skills.
| Historical Figure | Decade | Score | Historical Thinking Skill | Analysis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Andrew Carnegie | 1890s | -1 | Continuity and Change Over Time | Although he promoted a lot of economical and business growth, his methods of vertical integration were unorthodox and unethical. |
| William Randolph Hearst | 1900s | +4 | Causation | Hearst's use of yellow journalism to sensationalize the sinking of the USS Maine exemplifies how media manipulation can drive a nation to war, illustrating the dangerous intersection of press power and imperial ambition in the Spanish-American War. |
| Jeannette Rankin | 1910s | +5 | Argumentation | As the first woman elected to Congress, Jeannette Rankin's votes against U.S. entry into both World Wars reflect an unwavering commitment to pacifism and democratic principle, even at great personal political cost—a landmark in the evolution of women's political agency. |
| W.E.B. Du Bois | 1920s | +1 | Contextualization | Du Bois's concept of "double consciousness" and his co-founding of the NAACP represent a critical challenge to the racial hierarchy embedded in American society, though systemic racism limited the immediate impact of his intellectual and activist contributions. |
| Huey Long | 1930s | +3 | Comparison | He was a far-left Democrat who was a staunch opponent of Roosevelt's New Deal, arguing it did not go far enough. His "Share Our Wealth" program proposed radical redistribution, making him both a champion of the poor and a cautionary example of populist demagoguery. |
| Franklin Delano Roosevelt | 1940s | +4 | Continuity and Change Over Time | Franklin Delano Roosevelt created the New Deal, a set of government programs to help alleviate the economy after the Great Depression. This shows a stark change from his predecessors who believed in Laissez-Faire capitalism, and that the economy would self-stabilize. He held out against entering World War II initially but only entered after interests of America were directly threatened. |
Andrew Carnegie
1890sContinuity and Change Over Time
Although he promoted a lot of economical and business growth, his methods of vertical integration were unorthodox and unethical.
William Randolph Hearst
1900sCausation
Hearst's use of yellow journalism to sensationalize the sinking of the USS Maine exemplifies how media manipulation can drive a nation to war, illustrating the dangerous intersection of press power and imperial ambition in the Spanish-American War.
Jeannette Rankin
1910sArgumentation
As the first woman elected to Congress, Jeannette Rankin's votes against U.S. entry into both World Wars reflect an unwavering commitment to pacifism and democratic principle, even at great personal political cost—a landmark in the evolution of women's political agency.
W.E.B. Du Bois
1920sContextualization
Du Bois's concept of "double consciousness" and his co-founding of the NAACP represent a critical challenge to the racial hierarchy embedded in American society, though systemic racism limited the immediate impact of his intellectual and activist contributions.
Huey Long
1930sComparison
He was a far-left Democrat who was a staunch opponent of Roosevelt's New Deal, arguing it did not go far enough. His "Share Our Wealth" program proposed radical redistribution, making him both a champion of the poor and a cautionary example of populist demagoguery.
Franklin Delano Roosevelt
1940sContinuity and Change Over Time
Franklin Delano Roosevelt created the New Deal, a set of government programs to help alleviate the economy after the Great Depression. This shows a stark change from his predecessors who believed in Laissez-Faire capitalism, and that the economy would self-stabilize. He held out against entering World War II initially but only entered after interests of America were directly threatened.